Here's the Real Cost of Having Too Much in Your Savings Account
KEY POINTS
- We all need savings, but you can have too much of a good thing.
- If you have more than three to six months of living expenses in savings, you could be missing out on other opportunities.
- Investing carries more risk, but it may pay higher returns in the long term.
Savings are wonderful things. Last month, my boiler exploded and burst a bunch of pipes. Those kinds of emergencies are never fun, but the fact that I had cash in my emergency fund made it less stressful. I could pay for the plumber, builder, and emergency gas repairs without using my credit card.
The high interest rates we've seen in the past few years mean there's another bonus to having savings: the best high-yield savings accounts pay great interest rates. Recently, we've seen APYs of 4% or 5% or more. If you've got $8,000 in savings, you could have earned at least $320 in interest earnings for 2024.
But savings accounts are only one financial tool. And if you keep too much money in yours, you could be missing out on returns from investing.
Here's how you can have too much in your savings account
It's important to give each bucket of your money a purpose so that you can put it to work effectively. For example, checking accounts rarely pay enough interest to stay ahead of inflation. But they are an extremely useful way to manage all your everyday transactions.
Savings accounts are a great place for cash you might need to access quickly. Importantly, they are safe -- your balance won't fluctuate if the stock market performs badly and most accounts are covered against bank failure by FDIC insurance. Plus, some high-yield savings accounts are still paying APYs of over 4% right now. Click here to learn more about how this no-monthly-fee account could be a good home for your savings.
But the rate you'll earn on your savings -- even money in a high-yield account -- won't be enough to build your retirement nest egg. The ideal is to keep around three to six months' worth of living expenses in your savings account. But if you put too much in there, you're missing out on the potential gains you'd get from investing.
Investing carries more risk, but over time you can earn higher returns. If you're thinking long term, investing is a proven way to build wealth. Even so, it doesn't make sense to put your emergency fund in a brokerage account because the value of your portfolio can change from day to day. If you face an unexpected financial crisis, you might be forced to sell assets at a loss.
To summarize where your money goes:
- Checking account: Everyday spending money. Low risk with extremely low returns.
- Savings account: Cash you might need in the short to medium term. Low risk with limited returns.
- Investment account: Longer-term wealth building. More risk with potential for higher returns. Click here for our selection of the best low-fee brokerage accounts.
A few percentage points makes a lot of difference
The potential return on your investments depends on your strategy, how much risk you're willing to take, and the way you manage your portfolio. Many financial planners use an average 8% investment return as a rule of thumb.
That's a pretty realistic figure. The S&P 500 -- often used as a benchmark for stock market performance -- has averaged an 8% annual return over the past 100 years or so.
In contrast, the FDIC says average savings account APYs are just 0.42% right now. High-yield accounts pay more, but there's a strong chance savings rates will fall further next year as the Fed continues to cut its benchmark interest rate.
You're unlikely to be able to earn 4% on your savings for the coming 20, 30, or 40 years. But for the sake of simplicity, let's assume you can. Let's say you save or invest $500 a month. Here's roughly how much your balance might grow at different rates over time.
Timeframe | 4% APY | 8% APY |
---|---|---|
10 years | $72,000 | $87,000 |
20 years | $179,000 | $275,000 |
30 years | $337,000 | $680,000 |
40 years | $570,000 | $1,554,000 |
Inflation will eat into your savings
Inflation is the boogeyman for savers and investors alike. As prices increase, the money you've saved won't go as far. In summer 2022, inflation hit a 40-year high at 9.1% -- way ahead of even the highest savings account APYs.
If the APY on your savings account is not as high as the rate of inflation, you're effectively losing money. That's the real cost of having too much in your savings account. Not only are you not earning the returns you might get from your investments in the long term, but you could also be falling behind any inflationary tides.
Our Research Expert
We're firm believers in the Golden Rule, which is why editorial opinions are ours alone and have not been previously reviewed, approved, or endorsed by included advertisers. Motley Fool Money does not cover all offers on the market. Motley Fool Money is 100% owned and operated by The Motley Fool. Our knowledgeable team of personal finance editors and analysts are employed by The Motley Fool and held to the same set of publishing standards and editorial integrity while maintaining professional separation from the analysts and editors on other Motley Fool brands.